Coliform bacteria slowly adapt to the presence of attractants and repellents by altering the methylation state of their receptors to restore the pre-stimulus swimming behaviour. These methylation and demethylation reactions can be implemented in either a fine-tuned or a robust manner [Barkai & Leibler (1997) Nature 387:913-917]. In the fine-tuned approach, the net rate of receptor modification depends on the concentrations of the receptor species; in the robust approach, the net rate of receptor modification depends on the activities of the receptor species. With a square pulse of aspartate from 100 s to 600 s for a range of aspartate concentrations, the differences between the two approaches become apparent.

 

Fine-tuned adaptation to aspartate (BCT 4.0)

Here, the reaction network has been fine tuned to give exact adaptation at 1 µM aspartate. At any other concentration, adaptation still occurs but is no longer exact.

 

Robust (exact) adaptation to aspartate (BCT 4.2)

Note that de-adaptation is more rapid than adaptation and that adaptation takes longer at high aspartate levels. Both these features of robust adaptation are in accord with experimental observations.

 

Robust (exact) adaptation to nickel (Ni++)